Zafarano Dr C3 · Santa Fe

Santa Fe Pizza Night: Amalfi, Cafe Grazie and Piazza Caffe

Family-owned Pizzeria Amalfi on Saint Michael's Drive, neighborhood Italian and Mediterranean at Cafe Grazie, and Roman-style thin-crust pizza at Piazza Caffe.

By Anthony Dazet, City Editor

October 23, 2026 · 5 min read

Ask LIVI about Cafe Grazie Join free to save it Advertise your business

Santa Fe Pizza Night: Amalfi, Cafe Grazie and Piazza Caffe — Pepperoni pizza with a puffed, browned crust at Pizzeria Amalfi. Photo: LIVIN.in

We, the LIVIN team, ate at Pizzeria Amalfi on September 11, 2026. Our photo shows a pepperoni pizza with a puffed, browned crust on a white plate. Our photo shows three fried arancini topped with grated cheese and herbs, next to a bowl of red sauce. Our photo shows a square of tiramisu dusted with cocoa on a white plate.

The LIVIN team photographed the Amalfi menu that visit. Our photo shows the two pages of the Amalfi menu: appetizers, salads and panini on one page, and pizza and pasta on the other. The Amalfi menu pages have the name Amalfi in red script at the top.

This guide has three stops. Pizzeria Amalfi on Saint Michaels does Caputo flour pizza and pasta. Cafe Grazie on Zafarano does neighborhood Italian and Mediterranean brunch through dinner. Piazza Caffe on Camino Entrada does Roman-style pizza and house-made pasta.

Pizzeria Amalfi, 1722 Saint Michael's Drive

Pizzeria Amalfi is a pizza restaurant at 1722 Saint Michael's Drive in Santa Fe. Pizzeria Amalfi is family-owned. It opened in the building that was previously home to Pizzeria Espiritu. The original Pizzeria Espiritu was on Canyon Road, and its later location was at 1722 Saint Michael's Drive. Pizzeria Espiritu closed earlier in 2026. As of August 4, 2026, Pizzeria Amalfi had been open about two weeks.

City MVP spot · For businessOwn a business in Santa Fe?Put it in front of people reading Santa Fe stories, in a City MVP spot marked as sponsored.Advertise your business

The Amalfi menu says its pizzas are made with premium Caputo Italian 00 flour for a light, crisp crust, with a choice of 9 inch or 12 inch. On the Amalfi menu, the Margherita pizza is $10 to $15, with Italian plum tomato sauce, fresh mozzarella, basil and EVOO. On the Amalfi menu, the Pepperoni pizza is $12 to $18, with Italian plum tomato sauce, pepperoni, mozzarella, pecorino, oregano and EVOO. On the Amalfi menu, the Prosciutto pizza is $14 to $20, with Italian plum tomato sauce, mozzarella, Gran Premio prosciutto, arugula, balsamic glaze, fig jam and parmesan. On the Amalfi menu, the Bianca pizza is $13 to $19, with alfredo, chicken, mozzarella, artichokes, spinach, red onions, green chile and a pesto drizzle. On the Amalfi menu, Build Your Own pizza is $9 to $14, and toppings include green chile, jalapeno, kalamata olives, truffle oil and burrata.

On the Amalfi menu, pastas include Fettuccine Alfredo for $17, Pappardelle Bolognese for $22, Lasagna Bolognese for $21 and Frutti di Mare for $29. On the Amalfi menu, Spaghetti Meatballs are $21, with house-made meatballs of ground beef and pork. On the Amalfi menu, Arancini are $11: risotto orbs with parmesan, basil and marinara sauce. On the Amalfi menu, Garlic Bread is $6: toasted ciabatta with home-made garlic butter. Pizzeria Amalfi offers a number of mocktails and serves Jarritos.

Online listings checked October 19, 2026 show Amalfi Pizzeria open Tuesday to Sunday from 11 am to 8 pm and closed Monday. Online listings give the Amalfi Pizzeria phone number as (505) 477-1417. Confirm same-day hours before you go.

The two-page Pizzeria Amalfi menu. Photo: Anthony Dazet

Cafe Grazie, 3530 Zafarano Drive

Cafe Grazie is an Italian and Mediterranean neighborhood restaurant. The Cafe Grazie contact page gives the address 3530 Zafarano Drive, Suite C3, Santa Fe, NM. The Cafe Grazie contact page gives its location as 3530 Zafarano Drive, Santa Fe, NM 87507, next to Domino's.

City MVP spot · For businessYour business, inside the story.A City MVP placement in Santa Fe stories, next to what locals are reading.Advertise your business

Cafe Grazie's contact page lists Monday to Saturday dine-in, takeout and delivery hours: brunch and lunch 11 am to 3 pm, and dinner 5 pm to 9 pm. The Cafe Grazie contact page lists Sunday as closed.

Our Grazie photo shows a pasta plate of spaghetti topped with chicken and capers in a white bowl. Our Grazie photo shows a baked dish under browned, melted cheese on red sauce.

Three fried arancini with red sauce at Pizzeria Amalfi. Photo: Anthony Dazet

Piazza Caffe, 2574 Camino Entrada

Piazza Caffe is an Italian restaurant in Santa Fe. The Piazza Caffe location page lists 2574 Camino Entrada, Santa Fe, New Mexico 87507, and the phone number 505-303-3912. Piazza Caffe says its approach is Italian-Italian, not Italian-American, but cooking as it is done in Italy. At Piazza Caffe, house-made pasta and Roman-style thin-crust pizza anchor the menu.

The Piazza Caffe home page names Cacio e Pepe, Carbonara and Lasagna Bolognese, plus Roman-style thin-crust pizza and focaccia baked daily. The Piazza Caffe home page also names Chicken Cacciatore, pork chops with wild mushrooms and Eggplant Parmigiana. Piazza Caffe calls itself a place for aperitivo, dinner and unhurried evenings.

The Piazza Caffe home page and location page both list Closed Tuesdays. The Piazza Caffe location page lists Happy Hour in the bar from 4 pm to 6 pm. Confirm same-day hours before you go.

City MVP spot · For businessReach Santa Fe readers.A City MVP spot beside Santa Fe stories, where locals decide where to go next.Advertise your business

Our Piazza photo shows a tangle of thick pasta under grated cheese and cracked black pepper. Our Piazza exterior photo shows the sign over the windows reading piazza caffe, Trattoria di Famiglia. Our Piazza exterior photo was taken at dusk and shows white roses in front of the windows.

Tiramisu dusted with cocoa at Pizzeria Amalfi. Photo: Anthony Dazet

When each kitchen is closed

Piazza Caffe is closed Tuesdays. The Cafe Grazie contact page lists Sunday as closed. Online listings show Amalfi Pizzeria closed Monday. Confirm same-day hours before you go.

Spaghetti with chicken and capers, and a baked dish under melted cheese, at Cafe Grazie. Photo: Anthony Dazet

How to build the night

Pick Pizzeria Amalfi when you want Caputo flour pizza. Pick Piazza Caffe on Camino Entrada when you want Roman-style thin crust.

For two stops, have lunch at Cafe Grazie, whose contact page lists brunch and lunch from 11 am to 3 pm, Monday to Saturday, then dinner at Piazza Caffe, which calls itself a place for aperitivo, dinner and unhurried evenings. The Piazza Caffe location page lists Happy Hour in the bar from 4 pm to 6 pm.

The same two Cafe Grazie plates from another angle. Photo: Anthony Dazet

Quick answers

Pizzeria Amalfi is a pizza restaurant at 1722 Saint Michael's Drive. Cafe Grazie is an Italian and Mediterranean neighborhood restaurant at 3530 Zafarano Drive, Suite C3. Piazza Caffe is an Italian restaurant at 2574 Camino Entrada.

The Amalfi menu says its pizzas are made with premium Caputo Italian 00 flour. At Piazza Caffe, house-made pasta and Roman-style thin-crust pizza anchor the menu. Confirm same-day hours before you go.

The Cafe Grazie contact page lists Sunday as closed. The Piazza Caffe home page and location page both list Closed Tuesdays. Online listings show Amalfi Pizzeria closed Monday.